best Culver’s items You Absolutely Have to Try

✅ Going to Culver’s? Try These 7 Best Culver’s Items!

If you’re heading to Culver’s and stuck thinking “What should I order?” — don’t worry, I’ve got you. I’ve tried Culver’s a bunch of times myself, and I’ve also gone through real customer reviews to find out which items are the most loved on their menu.

So whether it’s your first visit or your fiftieth, here are 7 Culver’s must-try items that people can’t stop talking about:

🍔 1. ButterBurger® (The Original)

This is Culver’s signature burger — simple, juicy, and made with fresh Midwest beef. It’s cooked to order and served on a lightly buttered bun. Classic done right.

🔥 What’s Inside?

• Fresh Midwest beef patty
• Lightly buttered, toasted bun
• Pickles, onions (optional), ketchup, mustard

😋 Taste & Experience

You get that rich, juicy beef flavor right away — nothing frozen here. The buttered bun adds a soft, slightly crispy texture, and everything just melts together perfectly in each bite. It’s simple, but it hits just right.

“Tried it once and now it’s hard to enjoy burgers from anywhere else.”

🧾 Why customers love it:

“Hands down the juiciest fast-food burger out there. Simple, classic, and always satisfying.”

🧀 2. Wisconsin Cheese Curds

These deep-fried cheese curds are a total fan favorite. Crunchy on the outside, melty on the inside — and made from real Wisconsin cheddar. One of Culver’s most iconic sides — real Wisconsin white and yellow cheddar curds, deep-fried until golden and gooey.

🔥 What’s Inside?

• Fresh Wisconsin cheddar cheese (white & yellow)
• Light crispy batter
• Fried to golden perfection

😋 Taste & Experience

The outside has a light, crispy crunch, but the real magic happens inside — warm, stretchy, melty cheese that just pulls apart. They’re salty, creamy, and seriously addictive. They make the perfect snack, side, or even a cheesy meal if you go big.

“Honestly, I go to Culver’s just for the cheese curds. They’re THAT good.”

🧾 Why customers love it:

“If you haven’t tried their cheese curds, you’re missing out on the ultimate Midwestern snack.”

🍦 3. Fresh Frozen Custard

Richer and smoother than ice cream, Culver’s frozen custard is made fresh all day. You can go for the flavor of the day, a sundae, or mix it up in a Concrete Mixer. Culver’s rich, creamy frozen dessert made fresh every day — smoother and denser than regular ice cream.

🔥 What’s Inside?

• Fresh farm dairy
• Egg yolks for extra richness
• Daily rotating flavors (like Turtle, Brownie Batter, Raspberry Cheesecake, etc.)
• Optional toppings: fudge, caramel, sprinkles, cookie dough

😋 Taste & Experience

It’s thicker, smoother, and more velvety than your average ice cream. Because it’s made in small batches throughout the day, it’s always fresh and full of flavor. Whether you go for a sundae, a cone, or a Concrete Mixer, it always feels like a treat made just for you.

“I usually go for the burger, but I always leave with custard too.”

🧾 Why customers love it:

“I come for the ButterBurger but stay for the custard. It’s rich, thick, and absolutely delicious.”

🐟 4. North Atlantic Cod Filet Sandwich

Light, crispy, and hand-battered to order — this one surprises people. Great choice if you’re not in the mood for beef or just want something fresh. A light, crispy fish sandwich made with hand-battered North Atlantic cod and topped with fresh ingredients.

🔥 What’s Inside?

• Wild-caught North Atlantic cod
• Hand-battered and golden-fried
• Shredded lettuce
• Tartar sauce
• Toasted hoagie-style bun

😋 Taste & Experience

This sandwich feels more like something you’d get at a local seafood spot than a fast-food chain. The fish is flaky and fresh inside, with a crisp golden coating outside. Paired with cool tartar sauce and a soft bun, it’s surprisingly satisfying — especially if you’re looking for something lighter than beef or chicken.

“Didn’t expect a fast-food fish sandwich to taste this good.”

🧾 Why customers love it:

“Not your average fast-food fish sandwich. It’s actually fresh and flavorful!”

🐔 5. Crispy Chicken Sandwich

Tender chicken breast, perfectly crispy outside, and served with pickles on a buttered bun. If you’re a chicken sandwich fan, Culver’s version won’t disappoint. A classic done right — tender chicken breast, seasoned and fried until golden, served on a soft, buttered bun.

🔥 What’s Inside?

• Whole white meat chicken breast
• Crispy seasoned breading
• Dill pickles (optional toppings vary)
• Lightly buttered toasted bun

😋 Taste & Experience

Bite into a crispy, crunchy outer layer, and you’ll find juicy, tender chicken inside. It doesn’t taste processed — it tastes real. The toasted bun adds that soft balance, and the pickles give it a little zing. It’s a simple sandwich, but it hits hard for chicken lovers.

“Way better than most chicken sandwiches out there — tastes more real.”

🧾 Why customers love it:

“Tastes homemade, not processed. Way better than most fast-food chicken sandwiches.”

🍄 6. Mushroom & Swiss ButterBurger

If you like a little extra flavor, this one’s for you. Melted Swiss cheese with sautéed mushrooms on that same buttery bun — feels gourmet but it’s still Culver’s. Culver’s take on a savory classic — sautéed mushrooms, melted Swiss, and a fresh beef patty served on their signature buttery bun.

🔥 What’s Inside?

• Fresh Midwest beef patty
• Sautéed white mushrooms
• Melted Swiss cheese
• Lightly buttered, toasted bun

😋 Taste & Experience

This one’s all about that rich, umami flavor. The mushrooms are soft and juicy, the Swiss cheese melts beautifully, and the beef is always fresh and full of flavor. Each bite is warm, earthy, and super satisfying — feels more like a gourmet burger than fast food.

“Tastes like something from a diner, not a drive-thru.”

🧾 Why customers love it:

“So rich and flavorful—reminds me of a steakhouse burger.”

🌶️ 7. George’s Chili

Culver’s homemade-style chili is warm, hearty, and actually really filling. It’s not just a side — it’s comfort food. A comforting, homestyle chili that’s been part of Culver’s menu for years — perfect when you’re craving something warm and hearty.

🔥 What’s Inside?

• Ground beef
• Freshly chopped onions
• Tomatoes and kidney beans
• Special blend of chili spices
• Slow-simmered for rich flavor

😋 Taste & Experience

It’s thick, meaty, and just the right amount of spicy. You can tell it’s not from a can — it tastes homemade. Whether you’re having it as a side or a full meal, it really hits the spot. Especially good on cold days or when you’re in a cozy, comfort food mood.

“This chili hits different when it’s cold outside. I crave it.”

🧾 Why customers love it:

“I crave this chili when it’s cold out. It’s thick, meaty, and actually tastes homemade.”

📝 Final Thoughts: What Should You Try First at Culver’s?

Whether you’re a first-time visitor or a regular looking to try something new, these 7 menu items are highly recommended by real Culver’s fans. From main dishes to signature sides and iconic desserts, Culver’s delivers that warm, satisfying, made-to-order experience every time.

🔎 Related Searches You Might Be Wondering:

• What is Culver’s most popular item?
• What is the best frozen custard flavor at Culver’s?
• What’s healthier at Culver’s?
• What’s new on the Culver’s menu?

💬 Have a favorite Culver’s order that didn’t make the list? Drop it in the comments and let other fans know what to try next!